Aggressive or Just Reacting? Why Labels Don’t Tell the Whole Story

When someone says their dog is “aggressive” or “reactive,” what they’re usually doing is trying to make sense of behavior that feels intense, unpredictable, or embarrassing. Maybe the dog barked and lunged at another dog on a walk. Maybe they growled when someone reached to pet them. These moments can feel big—and they are—but the words we use to describe them often get in the way of actually understanding what’s happening. Aggressive and reactive aren’t diagnoses. They’re labels. And while they’re common, they can shut down curiosity and create fear, even when the behavior itself is entirely normal or expected. This blog looks at how those words shape our thinking, and what to pay attention to instead.

In the dog training world, labels like “reactive” or “aggressive” are often used as shorthand to describe certain patterns of behavior. They can feel helpful at first—offering a sense of community, a way to find resources, or simply language to explain what’s happening. But a label is still just that: a word we use to organize our understanding, not a full picture of what a dog is experiencing. And while labels can sometimes reduce overwhelm, they also risk oversimplifying complex behavior. They can lead us to make assumptions, overlook important context, or even miss the dog’s actual needs. It's easy to lose sight of what the behavior is trying to communicate.

Reactivity is one of the most common labels dogs receive. A dog might be called “reactive” if they bark and lunge on leash, bark at the front door, or bark too much inside the home. But here’s the thing: if we’re not reacting, we’re not alive. Reacting to stimuli in the environment is a normal, functional part of being a dog—and a human. Reactivity only becomes a problem when it starts to interfere with well-being or daily life. In other words, it becomes maladaptive. A behavior is only truly a problem if it’s causing ongoing stress or safety issues for the dog or the humans in their life.

Think about it this way: say you’ve had a rough day. You sat in traffic, dealt with a stressful meeting, and waited in a long line at the bank. When you finally walk through the door and see a sink full of dishes, you snap at your partner. Technically, you just reacted. But no one would call you a “reactive person” based on that moment alone. We’d recognize that you had a tough day and your response made sense in context. Dogs who bark or lunge or growl are doing the same thing—responding to something in their environment. Supporting those dogs means helping them feel safer, calmer and more comfortable in everyday life, not trying to eliminate all reactive behavior altogether. Reactivity doesn’t just show up or not—it exists on a spectrum. Maybe your dog hears a noise and glances toward the window. Totally normal. Maybe they check the window every time the wind shifts or a car drives by—that might be edging toward something more stressful. We do this too. All of us have yelled out loud before. Some of us have yelled at another person. Fewer of us have gotten into physical fights (though if you’ve got siblings, it might’ve happened). Even fewer have seriously hurt someone. The intensity, frequency, and impact of the behavior matter. And just like with humans, dogs can escalate in ways that reflect fear, overwhelm, or unmet needs—not a desire to cause harm. Understanding that range is key before we jump to the next label: “aggressive.” “Aggressive” is another label that dogs get assigned all the time—but like any label, it doesn’t tell us much about what’s actually happening. One person might call a dog aggressive for barking and growling. Another might use the same word to describe a dog who’s delivered multiple puncture wound bites. And someone else might describe a dog playing tug with growls and intensity as “aggressive” too. That’s a wide range of behavior to lump under the same term. Just like in the previous examples of human reactivity, reacting strongly doesn’t automatically mean something dangerous is happening. And just because a dog is barking and lunging doesn’t mean they’re going to bite. Some dogs do escalate quickly and require careful management and training. But most—like most people—never cross the line into true physical harm.

While it can be useful to acknowledge when a behavior is risky or unsafe, calling the dog “aggressive” as a fixed identity often shuts down deeper understanding. A dog growling once or twice isn’t automatically a problem. In fact, it’s often helpful—if you respect the growl and give the dog space or support, it may prevent things from escalating at all. Dogs are allowed to express themselves. And when we make space for those expressions, we can better understand how to support them rather than suppress them.

Now that we’ve looked at “reactive” and “aggressive” as just two of many labels people use to try and simplify complex behavior, you might be wondering: When does my dog’s behavior go from normal to something that needs support? In other words, when is it just a normal reaction—and when is it maladaptive?

One place to start is your dog’s basic functions. If their behavior is interfering with eating, digestion, or sleep, that’s a sign their nervous system may be struggling to regulate. A dog who scarfs food down, skips meals entirely, or has ongoing digestive issues may be experiencing more stress than their body can process. Same goes for sleep: if your dog regularly wakes in the night, paces, or can’t settle, that’s worth noting.

The second thing to look at is your own quality of life. If your dog’s behavior is disrupting your ability to rest, impacting your relationships with neighbors or housemates, or creating a safety concern for either of you, it’s likely a sign that support is needed.

You might also look at:

• How quickly your dog recovers from stress. If they stay tense or hypervigilant for long stretches after something happens, that may be a sign their coping skills aren’t strong enough yet.

• Whether the behavior is escalating in frequency or intensity—for example, a dog who barks occasionally at the window versus one who now lunges and growls every time someone walks by.

• If the behavior is limiting your dog’s access to the things they enjoy, like walks, play, or safe social time, because it’s too hard to manage their reactions in those contexts.

The goal of training isn’t to eliminate all expressions of emotion—it’s to help your dog (and you) navigate the world with more ease and less chronic stress.

Instead of labeling your dog’s behavior, try stepping back and looking at what’s actually happening using a framework called the ABC model: Antecedent, Behavior, Consequence. This approach helps you shift from judging the behavior to understanding the conditions that influence it. The antecedent is what happens right before the behavior—this might include who’s present, the time of day, the environment, or even how much sleep or activity your dog has had. The behavior is what your dog does, described clearly and specifically (like “barked three times and backed away” rather than just “freaked out”). The consequence is what happens right after: Does someone approach, move away, give a treat, or remove pressure? These patterns matter. When you start observing behavior this way, you’re more likely to uncover the actual reasons it’s happening—and how to support your dog through it—rather than getting stuck in labels like “reactive” or “aggressive.”

These patterns matter because they reveal what the behavior is doing for the dog. Every behavior serves a purpose—maybe it helps the dog avoid something they find stressful, get access to something they want, or regulate their own arousal. When we understand what’s triggering the behavior (the antecedent) and what’s reinforcing it (the consequence), we can start to change the conditions around it. That might mean adjusting the environment so the behavior doesn’t need to happen in the first place, or teaching the dog a new behavior that meets the same need in a safer way. For example, instead of lunging at a person approaching on a walk, the dog could learn to move behind their handler for safety. But that kind of progress doesn’t come from labeling a dog—it comes from watching, listening, and making thoughtful changes based on what the behavior is communicating. At the end of the day, labels like “reactive” or “aggressive” are just starting points—but they shouldn’t be the end of the conversation. Real progress comes from moving past those words and focusing on what’s actually happening: what your dog is feeling, what they’re responding to, and what they’re getting from the situation. When you look at behavior through that lens, you’re no longer guessing or assuming—you’re observing, adapting, and supporting your dog in ways that actually make a difference. You don’t need perfect language. You just need curiosity, compassion, and a willingness to look a little deeper.

---

🦴 Want to build your dog’s confidence and focus?

Get on the list for Game of Bones, a four-week online course packed with training games that help your dog explore, adapt, and learn new skills—all in just 10 minutes a day. You’ll be the first to know when it goes live.

[Join the waitlist for Game of Bones] 🐕 Dealing with leash reactivity?

Head to the Aggression Specialist page and scroll halfway down to grab your Free Guide: 6 Expert Tips for Managing Leash Reactive Dogs.This practical download is designed to help you reduce outbursts and navigate walks more safely—without using punishment or force.